Start from the facts, identify the legal rule, test the exceptions, document the evidence and only then determine the filing or operational action.
1. Start with the legal pattern, not the form
A1 is not a work permit. It certifies which Member State’s social-security legislation applies. The first task is therefore to identify the factual pattern before preparing an application.
Separate a temporary posting under Article 12 from habitual work in two or more States under Article 13. Mixing these routes is one of the most common reasons for a weak file.
2. Posting under Article 12: five tests that drive the result
For a standard posting, test the expected duration, the prohibition on replacement, the direct relationship with the sending employer, the employer’s substantial activity in Bulgaria and the worker’s prior attachment to Bulgarian legislation.
The 24-month maximum is not a stand-alone entitlement. A posting that lasts less than 24 months can still fail if the Bulgarian employer has no genuine activity or if the employment relationship has effectively moved to the host undertaking.
3. Work in two or more States: a different test
Article 13 is designed for a person who normally works in more than one Member State. The analysis focuses on the State of residence, the share of activity performed there, the employer or employers and their places of establishment.
Around 25% is an important indicator of a substantial part of the activity, but it is not a statutory safe harbour. The assessment should reflect the expected pattern over the relevant forward-looking period.
4. Facts that can reverse the conclusion
Contract wording is not enough. Review who directs the work, who can terminate the employment, who bears payroll cost, where the employer earns turnover, where contracts are negotiated and whether Bulgarian operations are genuine rather than purely administrative.
5. Evidence file
Build the file so that a third party can reconstruct the conclusion without oral explanations. Typical evidence includes the employment contract, posting order, commercial contract, payroll records, proof of Bulgarian business activity, turnover by country, work schedules and evidence of continuing managerial control.
6. Procedure and timing
Prepare the factual memorandum first, then complete the competent-institution procedure. If facts change during the assignment, reassess the legal basis rather than treating the original A1 as automatically valid for every later pattern.
7. What A1 does not solve
A1 does not replace host-country posted-worker notifications, minimum employment conditions, immigration/work-permit rules, permanent-establishment analysis, payroll obligations or VAT registration. These are parallel compliance tracks.
8. When to stop and redesign the structure
Pause before filing if there is little or no business activity in Bulgaria, the person is effectively managed abroad, the 24-month limit is expected to be exceeded, the posting replaces another worker, or the facts point to regular multi-State activity rather than a temporary assignment.
9. Final control list
Confirm the factual pattern, legal route, duration, residence, direct relationship, substantial activity, replacement test, evidence package and host-country obligations. Record the conclusion in a short internal memorandum before submission.
Official sources and further reading
Related interactive tool
This material is a general professional framework, not an individual legal or tax opinion. The outcome of a specific matter depends on the facts, contracts, documents, status of the parties and legislation in force at the relevant date.
